Scottsdale's plan to expand the Brown Avenue parking structure in Old Town has ignited a firestorm of debate among residents and business owners.

The proposed four-level garage, located at First Street and Brown Avenue, carries a hefty price tag of $18 million, translating to nearly $100,000 per parking stall.

City officials unveiled the design, emphasizing its Western-style architecture featuring textured concrete, brick accents, wood shutters, and covered walkways.

They argue that the cost reflects the project's commitment to preserving Scottsdale's unique aesthetic.

Long-time resident and business owner French Thompson supports the design, stating, "We're not building average America. We're building Scottsdale."

However, many community members are voicing strong opposition.

Small business owner and city council candidate Crystal Carroll is among those questioning the project's financial prudence.

Opponents argue that the garage will disrupt the historic character of Old Town and displace the beloved farmers market.

They have submitted over 4,000 petition signatures urging the city council to reconsider the project.

Scottsdale Mayor Lisa Borowsky has been a vocal critic, stating, "This is not an example of a quality location for a parking garage. It's in a historic district... and to bring 200 or more additional cars to that location is a really bad idea."

Despite the controversy, the city council approved a nearly $4 million construction contract for the project's first phase in a 5-2 vote.

Vice Mayor Adam Kwasman emphasized the necessity of addressing parking needs now, warning that delaying infrastructure improvements could lead to greater challenges in the future.

Construction is slated to begin this summer, with the garage expected to open in time for spring training 2027.

As the project moves forward, the community remains deeply divided, with ongoing petitions and debates highlighting the tension between development and preservation in Scottsdale's historic heart.